A few years ago a young British woman was murdered in Sienna, Italy. The case gained worldwide attention as the girls American roommate and friend was accused, tried, and convicted of the crime and then later acquitted on appeal.
The Face of an Angel is a fictionalization of this case. Sort of. Rather than going for the true crime, based on a true story type film director Michael Winterbottom and writer Paul Viragh instead opt to tell the story of a washed up film director in Sienna trying to find a story among the city, the massive media presence, and local characters during the appeal trial.
Yes, we’re basically talking about a director making a film about a director trying to make a film about a real life story. And also using Dante’s Inferno as a frame for the story. Yeah. It’s a bit weird. Not what I’d call bad, but definitely weird.
I actually really like what this film is shooting for. Daniel Bruhl’s Thomas spends the film exploring the media circus that surrounds the murder case and trying to figure out how to tell a truthful story when the truth is so horribly distorted. The films three acts line up with the three acts of Dante’s Inferno, first in hell Thomas is guided through the ridiculousness of the media coverage and everyone spinning the story for their own gain.
Next in Purgatory he becomes lost, stalled, trying to find some kind of meaning in the story, and meeting a young student who helps him connect with the city and decide how to break the story. He does a shit load of cocaine and is plagued by visions and dreams, most of which end in his violent death.
And lastly, in heaven, he decides he wants to make a film about love rather than about death, and attempts to give the victim of the crime some of the attention he believes she deserves.
Yeah, it’s a bit weird. Don’t get me wrong, it’s not bad. I’m not entirely convinced that it’s good either though. Daniel Bruhl is good, especially in the sections of the film where he being tortured by his own demons, and Cara Delevigne is pretty much spot on as the young student who guides him through the city. It’s hard to say if she’s a good actress because she’s pretty much spot on casting for this role but she’s one to watch regardless.
There are plenty of things that make this movie worth seeing. The press corps in Sienna is an amazing group of characters, the cinematography is fantastic, and there are some good central performances. The movie telling the story of a director trying to adapt a story concept I’m not sure I am entirely on board with but it’s interesting and you probably haven’t seen anything quite like it lately.
The film doesn’t quite reach it’s lofty goals though. For all the “I need to tell a story about love and we need to remember the victim” talk the film spends 99% of its time focused on Thomas and his demons as he figures that out rather than actually focusing on love or remembering the victim.